Best Cigar Humidor of 2019 Complete Reviews with Comparisons
The tobacco industry continues to grow, and that doesn’t come as a surprise, seeing that billions of people enjoy tobacco-derived products daily. Here we are not only talking about cigarettes but also shisha, as well as pipes, cigars, and cigarillos. While smoking these days is frowned upon, having an occasional cigar now and then shouldn’t hurt you in the long term.
We are saying this because expensive cigars are often present at business meetings as status symbols. If you have a supply of good cigars on your desk, you might as well put them in a proper storage box to ensure optimal quality and durability. What we are talking about are cigar humidors that come with a couple of benefits.
With the idea of helping you, we have prepared the best cigar humidor list as well as a detailed buyer’s guide and answers to the most frequently asked questions. So let’s get started and take a look at some of the top cigar humidors on the market.
Best Cigar HumidorComparison Chart
Scorch Torch Travel Cigar Humidor
Cigar Caddy Travel Humidor
Mrs. Borg Travel Cigar Humidor
Quality Importers Medici Humidor
Scotte Portable Travel Cigar Humidor
Best Cigar Humidor Reviews
1. Scorch Torch Travel Cigar Humidor
Cigars are a luxury product that is not for everyday use, which is the reason why investing in a proper humidor is a must. If you are always on the go and you want to have a couple on hand, then investing in this Scorch Torch product is the best thing that you can do. Made out of beautiful cedar and just the right size to fit 10 cigars, it is a great long-term investment toward your cigar-smoking enjoyment.
Product Highlights
Frankly, most names that have anything to do with cigars have been around for a couple of decades. While not as renowned, Scorch Torch is still a good company that has been manufacturing humidors with success for the past couple of years. With the 8.75×5.75×3.25 inch exterior as well as the 8x5x1.7 inch interior, it has a compact and convenient design that is perfect for taking on a trip. As you might know, the most important feature of any humidor is the humidifier.
In this case, it sits at 2.25 x 0.50 inches and is exceptionally efficient towards providing adequate levels of humidity and ensuring that your cigars stay in great shape. The design is attractive and elegant as the cherry cedar wood perfectly goes along with the idea of Cuban cigars. Now, while you can fit 10 cigars comfortably, there is still space for at least 10 more if you pack them horizontally.
Included with this product are the humidor case and the humidifier. There is also a handy user’s guide that will help you take good care of your travel case and cigars. Along with that, there is a butane lighter that varies depending on what particular set you order. A cutter tool has also been included and will prove essential when preparing a cigar.
There are two flaws to this product, which potentially can be overlooked. The first one is that the case lacks design detail, and the second is that we are not too satisfied with the smell. Other than that, there is nothing much to say against this humidor, as it indeed is a good gift for any faithful cigar smoker.
The Good
The perks of investing in the Scorch Torch Travel Humidor, we have to say, are the sturdy cedar wood design, as well as the efficient humidifier that achieves perfect results. This is what you are essentially looking for in a proper cigar humidor.
The Bad
On the other hand, we would prefer if the travel case had some more detail, whether those were engraved or simply printed onto the front or the sides of the humidor. Along with that, the smell of the travel case is quite important as it can impact the cigars, and while it is not bad, we think this one needs some improvements.
PROS
- checkCompact
- checkEfficient humidifier
- checkSpacious
CONS
- Lacking detailing
- Smell
CHECK LATEST PRICE ON AMAZON.COM
2. Cigar Caddy Travel Humidor
While the product mentioned above is elegant and great for traveling, other humidors are more substantial and are sturdier, if that is what you are looking for. One of the best examples is the cigar Caddy Travel Humidor. It may not be as attractive, but certainly is a great investment for any true cigar fan who wants this tobacco to stay in the best possible shape.
Product Highlights
It’s important to note that Cigar Caddy has been around for almost a few decades and that it is one of the most reputable brands when it comes to humidors. While it is primarily intended for the so-called Churchill cigars, in which you can fit up to 40 in the case, it can fit Cohibas as well. As long as you are familiar with the proper storage (horizontally), and you invest time to make sure that each cigar is exposed to the balanced levels of humidity, your cigars will retain their optimal texture and flavor.
Apart from the capacity, the design is on a different concept, as well. Made out of molded ABS plastic, this product is able to resist harsh conditions and even bumps on the road. While it is not as cool or elegant as a case that is made out of cedar, you are still getting much more utility and durability.
Unlike the humidor mentioned above, which was only available in a cherry cedar variation, this one is a full black matte that is simple yet practical. Apart from the features mentioned earlier, it has an airtight seal, and it can even float on the water or remain sealed at a 100 ft. depth. Still, this doesn’t mean that you should go all wild and test this claim.
There is an efficient humidifier disc that is integrated into the lid and ensures proper humidity for cigars. As for what you should be concerned about, apart from the fact that it does not look the most attractive on your desk, we would say it is the narrow foam inserts. Overall, it is a product that is worth your money because it offers hard shell protection and acts as a convenient travel case.
The Good
As we mentioned above, the best thing about this case is the sturdiness that it offers. Along with that, you are indeed getting a lot of space that can hold up to 40 different cigars. Thus, it is safe to say that the manufacturer didn’t go wrong with the given design.
The Bad
On the other hand, the foam inserts are a bit too narrow. Other than that, you might see this product only as a travel case as it is not something that you want to keep on your office desk.
PROS
- checkAir-tight, waterproof
- checkSpacious
- checkSturdy
CONS
- Narrow inserts
- Not as elegant-looking as could be
CHECK LATEST PRICE ON AMAZON.COM
3. Mrs. Borg Travel Cigar Humidor
If you are looking to buy an elegant and durable cigar humidor and you don’t mind the somewhat higher price, then Mrs. Borg Travel Cigar Humidor is something that you can enjoy. Coming in two beautiful variants, including beige and black matte, this compact travel case is perfect for people on the go and those who occasionally enjoy a high-quality Cuban cigar.
Product Highlights
Starting with the dimensions, this Mrs. Borg model is very compact and convenient, given the 8.4 x 5.1 x2.3 inch design. This one is both sturdy and extremely elegant, which is mostly due to the beautiful design and molded details. While the black matte is a classic choice, the beige one looks more luxurious and will undoubtedly fit any environment. Due to the efficient integrated humidifier, as well as the ABS plastic build, you are getting a quality product that will protect your cigars.
The main problem that we have with this product is the fact that the humidifier screen is not that readable. It is known to get stuck, showing the same value for a couple of hours. Other than that and the fact that it’s quite expensive, we don’t have many issues. The foam inserts and the two trays that can hold up to 10 cigars (combined) are a bonus to the overall value that this travel case carries. At the end of the day, if you are into buying from a trusted brand and you want something that will last, we recommend this humidor.
The Good
The fact that this product offers an airtight seal and an ABS protection that is lasting is what we like the most. Other than that, we have to say that the design is quite cool. And you can combine the best of both worlds — utility and elegance at the same time.
The Bad
So apart from the somewhat higher price given the fact that this humidor can fit only 10 cigars, we do have a problem with the fact that the humidifier screen doesn’t run as smoothly as you would expect it to do. This can be a problem as you are reading the incorrect value and thus thinking that the humidifier is not achieving the proper humidity levels.
PROS
- checkSturdy, air-tight build
- checkElegant
- checkQuality foam inserts
CONS
- Humidifier screen
- Pricey for some
CHECK LATEST PRICE ON AMAZON.COM
4. Quality Importers Medici Humidor
Moving on with our top cigar humidor list, it is time that we go ahead and present a product that can hold up to 500 cigars at a single time. Manufactured by Quality Importers, and made in the so-called Medici style, this is a product that will look beautiful on any cedar desk. Not only is it extremely attractive, but it also features two humidifiers that should ensure the optimal conditions and keep your cigars ready for enjoyment.
Product Highlights
The first thing that we will be discussing for this product is the astonishing design. Starting off with the full cedar build, it is accented by a gold-plated lock and a key. Along with that, there are the quadrant and piano hinges that add to the utility and the elegance of this humidor. One of the most praised details of this cigar case is the walnut finish that looks beautiful, and that truly underlines the idea of Medieval Italy.
As we mentioned above, not only is it a beautiful product, but also a very well-built humidor. This is due to the fact that it includes two efficient humidity controllers, as well as one glass hygrometer that not many products come with. While the lock is not the sturdiest feature of this product, the air-tight seal still ensures that the cigars are protected from any damage (apart from the robbery).
The humidor features two trays that can hold up to 500 cigars. Along with it is the scratch-resistant bottom that we see as one of the best design details on the market. Not only that, but there are also two Spanish cedar dividers that should ensure there is enough place for all the cigars without one affecting another. Yes, the lock is kind of flimsy, but other than that, we really can’t see the reason why you would slip up on such a good offer.
The Good
We simply love everything about this Medici-style humidor that is elegant, smooth, and spacious. Apart from the many details that both the exterior and interior feature, we see the two humidifiers as the perfect amount for controlling the humidity levels in a case like this (given the dimensions and material).
The Bad
On the other hand, the lock is not as sturdy as it should be. While it does look nice given the fact that it is gold-plated, we still think that replacing the locks would be a better solution. Also, as there is a lot of space, putting only a few cigars will result in a lot of loose movement around the box.
PROS
- checkAffordable
- checkSpacious
- checkGreat design
CONS
- Flimsy lock
- Loose fit
CHECK LATEST PRICE ON AMAZON.COM
5. Scotte Portable Travel Cigar Humidor
If you are looking for a small and convenient humidor for your Cohiba cigars, then we have the right product for you. The Scotte Portable is affordable and sturdy, providing all that you need for when you are on the go. A great leather-cedar design and a unique ostrich pattern are what highlight this stunning product.
Product Highlights
We always emphasize that the design is critical in terms of combining elegance and utility. Now, this small humidor comes with a few cool features, including the humidifier, as well as the cigar cutter, and a couple of strapped pockets for small accessories. When it comes to capacity, you can put up to 4 cigars in it, that should be held in place by the leather straps. Still, we want to let you now that these are not that sturdy.
Other than the great inner design, the exterior is attractive, nonetheless, as the ostrich pattern makes for a pretty good finish. While the zipper feature is convenient, it is not as secure as an airtight lid but still contributes to the whole leather design of this product.
While there is no warranty policy, you have a 30-day refund window in case you are not satisfied with this product. We see it as a great choice if you always like to have a few cigars on hand, but you don’t want the humidor to take a lot of space in your travel bag.
The Good
We love the fact that it is so slim and compact but still offers good protection and a secure zipper closure. Not only this, but the genuine leather that it is made of is quite sturdy as well.
The Bad
On the other hand, the leather straps, as mentioned above, seem to be quite flimsy. You will need to be extra cautious when using these to secure your cigars. Along with that, the zipper is not of the best quality either.
PROS
- checkGreat leather design
- checkEfficient humidifier
- checkCool cutter
CONS
- Flimsy straps
- Zipper is questionable quality
CHECK LATEST PRICE ON AMAZON.COM
Cigar Humidor Buyer’s Guide
In discussing how to choose a top cigar humidor. We want to mention that there are a couple of features that you want to look into. Yes, the brand and the price are always good indicators of the potential quality, but apart from that, there are few design-related points that you should pay attention to. In order to help you, we have prepared five of the most critical features, as well as an explanation of why these features matter.
Types of Humidors
As for the different types of humidors, these mostly differ in the material they are made of. While every proper humidor features a humidifier and a hygrometer, some are made of leather, others cedar, and still others are made out of ABS plastic. The latter certainly is the sturdiest choice, but the first one allows elegance and attractive design.
Hygrometer
When it comes to what a humidor has to include, the hygrometer is undoubtedly among these features. It is a device that is usually made out of glass, and the inner mechanical part measures the humidity as well as water evaporation.
Capacity
When we are talking about capacity, it all comes down to your personal needs and preference. While the last humidor that we have reviewed (Scotte) is suitable only for 4 cigars, the Medici-styled humidor can hold up to 500, which is simply astonishing. In our opinion, a 10-cigar travel case is an optimal choice for when you are on the road.
Humidifier
Along with the hygrometer, the humidifier is the device that is responsible for balancing the right levels of humidity. In most cases, there is a convenient lid that will allow you to replace humidifier discs now and then to ensure optimal performance.
Temperature
This all depends on the cigars that you are smoking, but in most cases, the ideal temperature for storage is somewhere around 20°-25° Celsius.
Cigar Humidor FAQ
What is a humidor?
A humidor is a product that is essential if you are a cigar smoker. It will keep those prized cigars protected from any external or internal damage. Tobacco is quite sensitive to humidity and temperature, which is the reason why the case you are storing them in matters. The humidor features a hygrometer and humidifier that both play an important role in maintaining the right temperature and levels of humidity.
Why do you need a humidor?
While you don’t have to invest in one, skipping on it may result in a loss of a lot of money. How so? The expensive cigars that you bought will be affected by wrong humidity levels and temperatures that can easily make the smell and taste go bad.
How long will cigars last if properly cared for?
This is a good question, and we have to say that it all depends on the cigar. Still, when in a humidor, most cigars can last for a few years, if not even more.
How do I calibrate my hygrometer?
This all depends on the model of the humidor that you have invested in, as well as if we are talking about a glass or some other type of hygrometer. Check the user’s guide, and be sure to recalibrate it every now and then as hygrometers can get stuck.
Do all cigars like the same conditions?
While the Churchill cigars do differ from the Cohibas when it comes to the tobacco that is used, as well as a number of few other details, most cigars do best at the same or similar temperature and humidity levels.
Conclusion
Coming to the conclusion of our article, we have to say that all five products that we have reviewed are of exceptional quality. Still, our personal favorite is the Mrs. Borg 10 Cigar Humidor as the optimal case for storage, and when you are on the go. It is sturdy and attractive at the same time, and while you are paying a somewhat higher price, we say it is worth it.
Now you know everything you need to know about the top cigar humidors on the market as well as how to choose one that suits your needs.
