Best Cigar Humidor for Beginner of 2019 Complete Reviews with Comparisons
When it comes to your cigar collection, you probably know they require storing in a perfect environment. Cigars lose their aroma and flavor with time, and if they lose their moisture, they are not worth smoking. They must be stored at a maintained humidity level to preserve their moisture.
A cigar humidor is a top need for everyone who either smokes cigars or keeps a collection for others. Whether you are looking for a cigar humidor for your cigar collection or as a gift for someone, we have you covered.
In this article, we have reviewed a few of the best cigar humidors available on the market. You can check the pros and cons of each to ensure that you are buying the right one for your needs.
Best Cigar Humidor for BeginnerComparison Chart
Mantello 25-50 Cigar Humidor
AMANCY Handmade 25-50 Cigar Humidor
XIFEI Acrylic Humidor Jar
Cigar Caddy 3240 Travel Cigar Humidor
Mrs. Brog Cigar Travel Humidor
Best Cigar Humidor for Beginner Reviews
1. Mantello 25-50 Cigar Humidor
One of the bestselling humidors by Mantello is made of Spanish cedarwood. This cost-effective humidor is perfect for beginners who are buying their first humidor. The glass top, with its gold plated hinges, gives it an expensive look. It takes care of your cigars by maintaining the humidity level in the box.
Review
This Mantello cigar humidor is a beautiful box to preserve the flavor and aroma of your cigars. This medium-capacity humidor has a cedar divider to store more than one collection of cigars. The kiln-dried Spanish cedar interior ensures that your cigars don’t lose their moisture, even when they are stored for a long time.
The analog hygrometer shows near to accurate readings of the humidity level. It maintains nearly 60 to 70 percent RH level most of the time. Sometimes it is unable to maintain the optimum humidity level due to sealing issues. Make sure that the box is sealed correctly, and the air is not escaping from anywhere to maintain the proper humidity level.
The dimensions of the Mantello cigar humidor are 10.5 x 9 x 4 inches. It can hold 25 to 50 cigars depending on the ring gauge. It weighs 3.8 pounds, which makes it easy to transport. However, you can use a travel cigar carrier if you want to carry just a couple of cigars and keep this as your main storage at home or in your office.
The package includes a humidor, humidifier, metal hygrometer, and a user manual. The user manual has enough details to use it correctly.
PROS
- checkElegant look
- checkHigh-quality build
- checkPerfect capacity
CONS
- Sealing problem
- Humidity maintenance issues
CHECK LATEST PRICE ON AMAZON.COM
2. AMANCY Handmade 25-50 Cigar Humidor
The AMANCY cigar humidor is a beautiful, handmade cigar case. The elegant look of the humidor makes it desirable to just about everyone. The leather finish gives it a classic look while the glass top makes it versatile. It’s a beautiful mixture of modern and traditional art. There is also a leather-finish cigar travel case that comes with the humidor.
Review
This feature-rich humidor by AMANCY is made from cedar. Cedar is known as the best natural material when it comes to making a humidor. It maintains the moisture with the help of a humidifier.
To check the humidity level, there is a built-in analog hygrometer. There are a few questions on its accuracy, as it doesn’t show an accurate humidity level. If you check with a manual hygrometer, there is always a difference of 5 to 10 percent. However, if you continuously keep the water filled, you will be able to preserve your cigars without much issue.
The construction of the humidor is flawless. It is a durable product which is going to stay with you for a long time. The kiln-drying procedure increases the life of the cedar.
The dimensions of the box are 10.2 x 8.6 x 3.9 inches. It weighs around 4 pounds, which is not difficult to carry if you travel frequently. It can hold 25 to 50 cigars depending on the ring gauge.
The package includes a humidor, cigar travel case, lighter, cigar cutter, hygrometer, cedar divider, and a user manual.
PROS
- checkLeather finish
- checkPerfect for beginners
- checkFlawless construction
- checkExcellent customer service
- checkDurable
CONS
- Inaccurate hygrometer
- Constant refilling
CHECK LATEST PRICE ON AMAZON.COM
3. XIFEI Acrylic Humidor Jar
This is a very stylish, elegant looking, HD transparent humidor. XIFEI has made this beauty with high-quality acrylic material. The tight seals and rubber gasket ensure it doesn’t leak any moisture. Unlike wooden humidors, you can view your cigars without opening it. The small size makes it a perfect companion while traveling.
Review
The acrylic material jar by XIFEI is a perfectly designed humidor for beginners. It keeps your cigars fresh and preserves their aroma with tight seals.
As per the instructions, you have to add a few drops of water to achieve around 65 percent to 75 percent humidity. However, the hygrometer is not very accurate. When measuring the humidity level with a separate digital hygrometer, there is a 5 percent discrepancy.
The height of this jar is 7.28 inches, with a diameter of 5 inches. It weighs only 1 pound and can hold up to 15 cigars. The height is questionable as it can hold most cigars but not those with over 7 inches in length like LFD Digger cigars. If you want to store cigars that are more than 7 inches in length, it is not for you.
The package includes a humidor, a built-in humidifier, a hygrometer, and a user manual. The instructions should be followed properly to maintain the humidity level.
PROS
- checkMaintain a good humidity level
- checkPerfect seals
- checkExcellent for starters
- checkStunning look
CONS
- Small size
- Non-adjustable hygrometer
CHECK LATEST PRICE ON AMAZON.COM
4. Cigar Caddy 3240 Travel Cigar Humidor
The Cigar Caddy 3240 is a 10-cigar waterproof travel humidor. The airtight seals and humidifier disc ensure the maintenance of the humidity level during your travels. The crushproof case can easily bear a temperature of -10° to 175° Fahrenheit.
Review
The Cigar Caddy 3240 is not one of the best looking humidors, but it has been designed for people who love to travel and explore the elements of nature. The cigar humidor is crushproof. It floats on water, and its airtight seal makes it water-resistant up to 100 feet. The black matte finish makes it dirt proof as well.
There is no hygrometer with this humidor. If you want to keep a check on the humidity level, you have to buy a separate hygrometer. This is the only downside of this product. Other than that, it maintains a humidity level at 65 to 75 percent most the time.
The exterior dimensions are 8 x 4 x 2.5 inches. It weighs less than a pound, making it a perfect traveling case. It can hold up to 10 cigars at once. However, if you would like to place a couple of humidity tubes in it, there will space for only eight cigars.
The package includes a crushproof travel humidor, stainless steel hinges, two removable clasps, a humidifier disc, and a user manual.
PROS
- check100% water resistant
- checkAirtight seal
- checkEasy to carry
- checkLightweight
- checkCrushproof
CONS
- No hygrometer
- Chemical smell
CHECK LATEST PRICE ON AMAZON.COM
5. Mrs. Brog Cigar Travel Humidor
Mrs. Brog is the producer of this mind-blowing humidor with aluminum for travelers — anyone who hits the road for an extended period needs this humidor. Its stylish design allows you to take it out anywhere. The gold color gives it an expensive look making it perfect for gifting to your loved ones.
Review
This Mrs. Brog cigar travel humidor is a lightweight cigar case for daily use. The humidor opens from both sides. The perfect airtight seals ensure that it doesn’t open accidentally. The aluminum case is hard enough to guarantee your cigars stay in shape under any circumstances.
The built-in hygrometer lets you check the humidity level at any time. There is also a humidifier to maintain the humidity level. When it comes to hygrometer readings, it is not as accurate as hoped. However, the humidifier works perfectly and retains the right level of humidity. It maintains 65 to 75 percent humidity all the time.
The height of this humidor is nearly 8 inches, and the diameter is 6.5 inches. It can hold two to four cigars depending on the ring gauge. It weighs less than a pound, which is easy to carry while traveling.
The package includes a humidor, hygrometer, humidifier, and user manual. It is available in three different colors, including gold, brown, and black.
PROS
- checkExpensive look
- checkLightweight
- checkMaintains humidity
- checkPerfect for travel
CONS
- Low capacity
- Inaccurate hygrometer
CHECK LATEST PRICE ON AMAZON.COM
Conclusion
When it comes to the best cigar humidor for beginner options, the Mantello 25-50 cigar humidor is large enough to hold a good number of cigars. It is cost-effective and perfectly maintains the humidity level.
If you are trying to find an efficient but stylish humidor, you can buy either AMANCY’s handmade leather humidor or XIFIE acrylic humidor jar. However, these humidors are not that good for travel due to their large size.
If you are looking for a small travel cigar humidor, the Mrs. Brog humidor is a good option. If you want more cigars while traveling and a solid case, you can go with cigar caddy 3240 travel cigar humidor. At the end of the day, if you are just starting out, any of the above options will suit you well, so select the one that suits your needs and budget best.